We’re creating affinity for Israel among young Americans which must not be taken for granted.
Bob Dylan once wrote something about changing times, and if you can’t lend a hand in the new path, you should step aside to make way for those who can.
Thanks to an out-of-box approach by a number of American organizations and some visionary thinkers at our very own Foreign Ministry, the future path of hasbara is rapidly changing forever. While this new approach doesn’t suggest that we abandon traditional methods of ‘explaining’ Israel’s positions, it certainly provides a complementary alternative outlook on not only how we conduct Israel advocacy, but how we want Israel to appear in the eyes of the world.
A week ago, 11 exhausted American journalists left Ben-Gurion Airport after spending eight days on a Youth Media junket to Israel sponsored by ISRAEL21c, the America-Israel Friendship League, America’s Voices in Israel, and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
The reason for the sleep deprivation wasn’t because of climbing the snake path to the top of Massada, or in-depth briefings on the Iranian nuclear threat from top think tank specialists, or meetings with high-ranking military officials or Knesset members.
Rather, it was due to staying up all night in the hottest Tel Aviv nightclubs, touring the restaurants of Jaffa on foot with famed chef Nir Zuk, learning about the Israeli companies who are creating the next ICQ, dining with exciting young author Etgar Keret, musical artists Ivry Lider, Idan Raichel, Hadag Nahash and Sagol 59, and discovering the latest cutting edge fashions in the burgeoning ‘Gan Hahashmal’ fashion design district of Tel Aviv.
For this wasn’t a group of reporters from The New York Times or the Wall Street Journal. In the words of Israeli journalist Uriel Heilman, who covered the visit for JTA, it consisted of “reporters from hipster music magazines, racy publications and teen glossies.”
While Israel’s hasbara is generally aimed at the readers of the staid, traditional media outlets like The Times, The Journal and CNN, a whole generation of Americans are eschewing those forms in favor of ‘new media’ – websites, blogs, podcasts, and magazines which cater to their interests in music, fashion, gadgets, trends and underground culture – media like Stuff, Paper, URB, Bust, Flaunt, and MTV’s Urge Web site.
When I was growing up, my generation subscribed to Rolling Stone – which provided ‘all the news that fit’ in regards to youth culture. Today, the palette is much broader, there isn’t one ‘center’ to youth culture, and young readers have a myriad of options to which to turn for information and entertainment.
These American consumers – aged 18-30 – are generally uninterested in the Middle East and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But the only images and information they’ve received over the last five years have been about suicide bombings, IDF raids, burned-out buses, and Ariel Sharon’s illness.
The purpose of the Youth Media Tour was to show the group of reporters and editors that write for the youth market that Israel is one cool place – bursting with music, sounds, food, ideas, opinions and youth culture – and provide them with concrete ideas for stories that they could write for their publications which would make Israel come alive and become more relevant to the lives of their readers.
Therefore, when the group attended a session on the Israeli film industry, hosted by Jerusalem Post film critic Hanna Brown, and were addressed by successful producer/directors Joseph Cedar (Campfire) and Gal Uchovsky (Yossi and Jagger), they were treated to advance screenings of the director’s upcoming films – both of which will be released in the US.
Likewise, when they attended a sneak-peek rehearsal of choreographer Emanuel Gat’s dance troupe at the Suzanne Dellal Center, they learned that the show they enjoyed would be performed later this year at New York City’s Lincoln Center.
Both of these are examples of Israeli culture which has nothing to do with the ‘matzav’, diplomacy, or… Palestinians.
A look at traditional hasbara efforts inevitably boils down to two words – Israeli and Palestinian. Entwined like a pretzel, it’s become virtually impossible to be able to get a word in edgewise about something to do with Israel without having to mention something to do with Palestinians in the next breath, or with a bit of luck, the next sentence.
We’ve allowed ourselves to let Israel’s enemies in the world set the agenda, and the main focus of Israeli hasbara activities since 1948 have been defensive, reactive responses to Palestinian claims or actions against us.
One of the main statements we’re trying to make with this trip is to say: Enough! We’re taking back the agenda!
Just as Israelis proved so resilient over the last five years of Palestinians attacks in their steadfast determination not to let it alter their everyday lives, the trip is a declaration of intent which says – not only will we continue to live creative, innovative and action-packed lives, we’re going to tell the world about it.
The trip in a nutshell? Wouldn’t it be better if some of the stories read by millions of young Americans who have no impression of Israel are about Israeli hip hop culture or Israel wind surfing culture – subjects that are relevant to those readers’ and viewers’ lives – rather than just the latest Palestinian atrocity, or the IDF response to that atrocity?
We’re not saying that the reality on the ground doesn’t exist – just that there’s another reality out there that defines Israel in terms that young Americans can identify with – hip, fun, and… relevant to their lives.
The result may not suddenly be a surge in tourism to Israel, but that’s not the goal we’re shooting for. By defining a new hasbara paradigm that focuses on reasons that Israel and America are alike culturally, we’re ultimately creating affinity for Israel among these young American readers – an affinity which must not be taken for granted.
Just because an older generation of Americans who lived through the Six-Day-War see their support for Israel as a no-brainer, it doesn’t necessarily mean their children will follow suit. Creating a new brand image of Israel among the younger generations could very well make that needed connection, and provide young Americans with a reason to care about this country.
By all means, we have to continue to strengthen our traditional hasbara – monitor anti-Israel media, bring over high level political delegations, lobby Capitol Hill, and continue defending Israel’s name and position wherever it is sullied.
But, we must not ignore this new avenue, which is going to reach millions of people who otherwise may continue to think of Israel in third world, war-torn terms – thousands of miles away and totally irrelevant to their lives.
And if, in the future, you see a bleary-eyed, hung-over American with a note pad sticking out his or her pocket, have a little compassion. They’re only researching the story called Israel.
(Originally appeared in The Jerusalem Post)