Israelis give a double punch to triple-negative breast cancer

Looking for an effective strategy against a particularly deadly form of breast cancer, Weizmann scientists have a potential winner.

Breast cancer can be curable if it’s caught soon enough – unless it is the “triple negative” type more likely to target young, black or Hispanic women.

Israeli researchers from the Weizmann Institute of Science in Rehovot are opening a new window of hope for the daughters and granddaughters of women diagnosed with triple-negative breast cancer. The cancer carries a strong genetic link and it is also found in people of Jewish Ashkenazi (Eastern European) ancestry.

“It’s quite a difficult disease,” says Prof. Yosef Yarden, a lead researcher in the new study from the institute’s Biological Regulation Department. “Women who are initially treated with chemotherapy show a good response, but they eventually develop resistance to the chemical therapy. They die within seven or eight years,” he tells ISRAEL21c.

Yarden and his colleague Prof. Michael Sela have determined that a two-antibody approach may increase survival rates, and reduce the odds of reoccurrence.

The cancer is called “triple negative” because it is lacking three hormone receptors that give fuel to most cancerous tumors –– estrogen, progesterone and HER2.

Successful hormone blockers like Herceptin do not work, and there is no solution for triple-negative cancer, Yarden says.

The Israelis’ experimental approach employs tactics to mimic the way the body normally defends itself against cancer.

Resisting arrest

As scientists do, Yarden and Sela began by studying the scientific literature to see what’s been done to solve the problem of triple-negative breast cancer. They challenged themselves to target the cancer in a new way: Instead of attacking one antibody on the tumor surface, which is how Herceptin works, they would look for another doorway.

They read that about 30 percent of all women with triple-negative cancer had higher than normal rates of EGFR, a growth hormone receptor. This presented a unique subtype of the triple-negative breast cancer to research.

Drugs that block EGFR have proven ineffective against these tumors. Going back to the drawing board, the Israeli team decided to deliver a double punch by combining two different antibodies to two different parts of the receptors.

And their hunch showed a positive effect: Breast-cancer cells shrunk in both animal models and in the Petri dish.

If this approach is developed into a drug, it might treat about five percent of all breast cancer patients, a meaningful proportion considering the aggressiveness of triple negative, says Yarden.

In their studies, the researchers subsequently uncovered a new cancer-blocking mechanism: using the double antibody approach, they were not only able to block EGFR, but the sheer weight of the antibodies attaching to the tumors caused individual cancer cells to collapse.

A breast-cancer vaccine?

While the tests are very positive, they have only been done on animals so far. Further collaboration with pharmaceutical companies will be needed to fund progress toward a viable drug alternative, Yarden says.

After their research was published in The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, industry and potential research partners started reaching out.

A new antibody is sought –– one that could synergistically activate the two already on the market. These two existing antibodies do not show a synergistic effect since they are both attracted to the same receptor on the cancer cell.

Genetic engineering and a molecular approach might be a step in the right direction, Yarden surmises.

A vaccination against cancer would be the ultimate goal.

“What we are doing is the building block for future vaccines –– either in active immunotherapy, where a patient will actively make antibodies; or in a passive approach, where we will provide the antibodies to the patient. Passive is used widely, while active is kind of a dream and a vision for the field. We have a much longer way to go,” says Yarden.

Related Articles

About Karin Kloosterman

Karin Kloosterman is an award-winning environment news publisher who founded Green Prophet ( to connect North Americans to issues that matter in the Middle East. She is the CEO of the Internet of Things startup flux, a company that is making social grow tools for urban farmers everywhere ( Karin can be reached at karin (at)
  • fredrik engstrom

    Is the conclusion that triple neg breast cancer is not curable and that the life expectancy after diagnose is max 7-8 years?

  • Patricia Whitehead

    While driving home, I heard on the news a very short insert, that Israeli University had a cure for cancer using Myrrh and that it cured every cancer known to mankind.. And that was all that was said about it..Does anyone know anything more concerning this subject???

  • Chris Ehlinger Cauffman

    Go Israel!!!! 4 yrs. ago I had a large triple neg. tumor. mastectomy, chemo, radiation. God truly blessed me!

  • Michael Winkles

    i hope they can find a cure, my wife died from this type cancer

  • Linda Tajik

    Your telling me I am going to die in 4 yrs. I was diagnosed in 2009 with triple negative and have been no evidence of disease since my chemo. Now I read I will die in a short time. Don’t like how this is worded. What they are doing is good if it works however I lost my confidence when I read triple negative patients in 7-8 years.

  • Kimberly Gartrell

    This article is NOT true. The stupid bitch who wrote this article claims that triple negative breast cancer is not curable and that people die from it, and that the life expectancy after diagnose is 7-8 years. That is an outright lie! This woman is not God. Who is she to say how long a person will live after getting a diagnoses of TNBC?

    I have a friend who is a 9 year survivor of Triple negative breast cancer so Karin you need to get your facts straight! You have absolutely NO clue what you are even talking about! You need to stop posting inaccurate information on the internet about a cancer you obviously don’t know enough about. I am also a 6 year survivor of triple negative breast cancer. And i have NOT had a recurrence. My doctor

    I encourage people to go over to the website and there you will find women who survivors of TNBC. One woman there is 23 year survivor and another is a 21 year survivor. Shame on you Karin for this article!!!

  • Kimberly Gartrell

    You don’t want to post my comments because you know this article that you wrote is full of bull. Shame on you and the professor who said that triple negative breast cancer is not curable.