Israeli ‘Carmen’ is a hot ticket in the desert

A young and relatively unknown mezzo soprano wows all at the foot of Masada.

The Israeli Opera returns to Masada this week with a majestic production of Bizet’s Carmen. On the backdrop of the stunning ancient fortress at the lowest point on Earth, the five open-air concerts will draw some 50,000 opera newcomers and devotees.

Since first staging Nabucco in 2010 and then Aida in 2011, the Israeli Opera has made it a tradition to stage a grand production annually at this magical setting.

Carmen. Photo by Yossi Zwecker

Carmen. Photo by Yossi Zwecker

And while there are many aspects of the show to write about, Israeli opera fans should remember this name: Na’ama Goldman.

The 26-year-old mezzo soprano was the talk of the General Rehearsal last night.

Listed briefly in the program as a cover for the roles of Mercedes and Carmen, Goldman was given the chance of a lifetime last night after Canarian Nancy Fabiola Herrera – who has performed the title role of Carmen all over the world — and Italian mezzo soprano Anna Malavasi – also meant to perform the title role – both called in sick (one fell and sprained her shoulder; the other had sinusitis).

Naama Goldman. Photo from Israeli Opera website

Naama Goldman. Photo from Israeli Opera website


Most of the audience had no idea that Goldman’s performance was the first time she was performing it on this stage. The young Israeli did a magnificent job and deserves the standing ovation she received when conductor Daniel Oren put his baton down.

Herrera was meant to take on the title role for the premiere. She performed the first two acts but then gave way to Goldman mid-show, citing a sore throat. Some critics said Goldman’s voice lacked maturity while others were blown away by the clarity. There was no denying the exceptional baptism-by-fire performances she gave.

It was Romanian soprano Brigitta Kele (Micaela), who happened to be sitting to my right, who told me about Goldman’s feat. Kele – who sported a hospital mask halfway through the opera – explained that for many of the international performers, the desert production was proving to be a strain on their voices.

The sand blown by the wind coupled with the desert heat had caused a number of the artists to suffer sore throats and stuffy noses.

Still, Kele said, she and her fellow visiting performers were only too happy to be in Israel. Kele – who is making her Israeli Opera debut with Carmen – raved about Tel Aviv (where first rehearsals were held) and said the desert setting really was exceptional.

Altogether, Carmen comprised 450 international performers, including 32 Spanish flamenco dancers.

The Israeli Opera regularly attracts an international cast. Artistic administrator Michael Ajzenstadt told ISRAEL21c last year that foreign singers, conductors and directors enjoy coming here for professional reasons. “There are hundreds of opera houses, but we’re an important house with prestigious connections around the world,” he said.

Of the three productions to take place at the foot of Masada, Carmen was being hailed as the most challenging to date.

Organizers said there were some 2,500 workers involved in creating the site — a 3,500 meter stage with 30 tons of lighting and sound fixtures and a reception area, parking and seating venue built from scratch and set to be completely dismantled the morning after the last show.

Add to that 3,000 magnificent costumes, 10 horses, seven donkeys, over 200 security personnel, the Rishon Lezion Symphony Orchestra, the Israeli Opera Choir, the Encore Youth Choir, the Tel Aviv Philharmonic choir and 25 marquees (which contained dressing rooms, make-up areas and dining services).

While impressive, it was the ‘who?’ that everyone asked about at the start of the production when the cast change was first announced, that turned out to be the most talked about aspect of the evening.

And, of course, that next year’s grand-scale opera at this spot will be Turandot – and that work on the production is already underway.

Related Articles

About Viva Sarah Press

Viva Sarah Press is an associate editor and writer at ISRAEL21c. She has extensive experience in reporting/editing in the print, online and broadcast fields. Her work has been published by international media outlets including Israel Television, CNN, Reuters, The Jerusalem Post and Time Out.